BENSON Boone’s ex-girlfriend Maggie Thurman has claimed that the singer was unfaithful during their relationship in a since-deleted TikTok video.
Benson, 23, and Maggie, 21, appeared to be the picture-perfect pairing since debuting their romance last year.
However, Maggie has insinuated that their recent break-up came after the Beautiful Things singer cheated on her.
She made the shocking claim in a TikTok in which the influencer lip-synced to audio from a scene in The Office where character Pam Beesly asks Kelly Kapoor, “Remember how it felt when he cheated on you?” and Kelly replies, “Which time?”
This sparked questions about the nature of Benson and Maggie’s split and whether infidelity played a part.
Maggie seemingly confirmed it did when a fan commented, “Bro if benson cheated i will turn this car right around,” and she responded, “Put your blinker on babe.”
The actress deleted the video shortly after, further raising eyebrows that she might have spilled details about her break-up with Benson.
She appeared to address the briefly posted clip in the comments of another recent post, where she wrote, “I got overwhelmed. I’ve always been a more private online person, tonight I remembered why. Thank you to everyone who was sending love, I appreciate yall so much.”
FANS’ REACTIONS
Fans discussed Maggie’s posts on Reddit after a user shared a screenshot of the video and her exchanges.
“Benson Boone doing a particularly guilty backflip,” one person wrote in the thread, mentioning the musician’s signature acrobatic move, which he performs at many of his shows.
“Moonbeam ice cream committing infidelity,” said another, referencing a lyric in Benson’s new single Mystical Magic.
“She’s witty though that comment made me LOL,” laughed a third.
“Super unsurprising. He’s so young and came into fame so quick,” added a fourth.
“She’s gorgeous! I’m sad for her, but I’m glad she found out now instead of down the road when they married and had kids,” chimed in a fifth.
‘IT SUCKS TO BE SAD’
Benson and Maggie split in early September after nearly two years together.
Although they didn’t formally announce the news, multiple outlets reported they’d parted ways, and they hinted that they’d ended their relationship.
The duo mutually unfollowed each other on social media, and Benson made a telling comment on stage.
“Sometimes people leave your life, whether it’s the right thing or the wrong thing. And it is always hard — always, every single time,” the In the Stars singer told the crowd.
He also said, “It sucks. And it sucks to sit in it, and it sucks to be sad about it.”
CAREER HIGHLIGHTS
Benson rose to fame after his jaw-dropping audition on American Idol in 2021, which earned him a trip to Hollywood.
He dropped out of the singing competition shortly after to pursue posting content online, which grabbed the attention of Imagine Dragons’ lead, Dan Reynolds, who signed the young artist to his record label, Night Street Records.
Benson has since been nominated at numerous award shows, including Best New Artist at the 2025 Grammy Awards.
According to his IMDb page, the Washington native earned himself a Video Music Award in 2024 for Best Alternative song for his mega-popular track, Beautiful Things.
He’s also the recipient of the 2025 Kids’ Choice Award for Favorite Male Breakout Artist.
