Sydnie Christmas has once again captivated audiences with a recent fan-recorded performance of Sara Bareilles’ “She Used To Be Mine,” delivered during her very first headlining show in America at Sony Hall, New York City, on April 8, 2025.
The musical theatre star, who shot to fame after winning ITV’s Britain’s Got Talent in 2024, left fans in awe, proving once more why many say she has “BROADWAY” written all over her.
The performance showcased Sydnie’s unique ability to tell a story through song, blending emotional depth with technical precision. Fans immediately took to social media to share their admiration. One remarked, “Sydnie truly is magic. It’s hard for me to think of another artist who can use dynamics, large and small flourishes, power, and precision all together to create and convey such emotion.” Another wrote, “The emotion in your voice is spellbinding! Absolutely beautiful, Sydnie!”
Many viewers drew comparisons to legendary vocalists while praising her originality. “Wonderful singer… top-notch in the tradition of the likes of Streisand, Dion, etc., but with her own style and voice,” said one fan. Others highlighted her ability to engage listeners on a personal level: “When Sydney sings a song, she tells a story and draws you into it! BRAVO!”
Comments reflected the deep connection her fans feel with her music. One follower shared, “Live YOUR BEST DREAMS SYDNIE. Thank you for this AMAZING RENDITION—I listen in memory of my gorgeous daughter, my forever angel.” Another emphasized her transformative power, saying, “This sounds pretty autobiographical… ‘She’ is now getting that opportunity to rewrite her ending! Yes!! I love that … and I love you.”
Even those new to her work were instantly impressed. “Since her BGT appearance, I became one of her followers. She is an excellent artist and this song was an amazing and very difficult song as well,” a fan noted. Another added, “She has that rare quality of being able to own a song!”
Despite her growing fame, Sydnie has remained grounded. In October 2025, she addressed concerns from fans who noticed her natural appearance on social media and feared she was overworked. She clarified, “I just haven’t got any makeup on. I’m just rocking what my mother gave me in that moment in time. I’m fine, I am completely fine!” The star emphasized that her natural look should not be mistaken for fatigue or illness, reassuring her 200,000 followers that she is in good health.
Since her BGT victory, Sydnie has maintained an impressive trajectory. She released the album My Way, performed for King Charles at the Royal Variety Performance, and mingled with music legends including Michael Bublé and Jennifer Hudson. Over the summer, she portrayed Cruella de Vil in 101 Dalmatians: The Musical, showcasing her versatility on stage. Yet, she remains down-to-earth about her growing fame, admitting, “I don’t get noticed, ever… Everyone recognised my friends, but not me. They thought that I was their manager.”
Sydnie’s journey from early performances in her kitchen to headlining shows in New York illustrates both her talent and perseverance. Fans continue to celebrate her achievements online, praising her vocal control, emotional storytelling, and the sheer joy she brings to each performance. One summed it up: “Sydnie, only your version of this song touched my heart like none of the others. I listen to your songs every day; I do not think I will ever get tired of hearing you sing. This one brings tears to my eyes every time.”
With her combination of vocal mastery, heartfelt interpretation, and unassuming personality, Sydnie Christmas has proven that she is more than a rising star—she is a musical force poised to make a lasting impact on Broadway and beyond.
